White Papers


The Economics of Downtime
September 2011 | Author: Baji Gobburi

A key cost that is seldom estimated during evaluation of various technologies in seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) projects is the cost of downtime, both planned and unplanned.This paper will prove that these downtime costs are significant to both the investors and the operators of the plant. Therefore plant availability must be a primary factor to be considered in the design phase. Plant availability is even more critical in evaluating the energy recovery technologies as they can cripple production if they break down often and require high maintenance.

Energy recovery devices (ERD) cost less than 2% of initial capital costs but could cost twice that due to lost margin and capital costs. Due to large initial capital expenses, long project life, and criticality of water for end-users, every component should be designed for longevity and robustness along with highest performance. As many plant operators have to pay for liquidated damages when missing the minimum production requirements, it is imperative that the plant is designed for the highest availability possible.

Download PDF

The Availability Advantage of Reliable Energy Recovery Technologies
September 2011 | Author: Rodney Clemente

Availability can be defined as the probability that a system or piece of equipment when used under the specified conditions operates satisfactorily at any given time. The availability of the equipment installed in a seawater reverse osmosis facility (SWRO) is extremely important to the price, quality and quantity of the final product – water. There are three critical components in the SWRO processes; the main high-pressure feed pumps, the RO membranes, and the energy recovery device (ERD) system. This paper focuses on the economic benefits and importance of the availability of energy recovery devices in SWRO desalination plants.
The largest operating expense for an SWRO facility is the power consumed, which accounts for approximately 30% of the total RO operating expense. Typically for large facilities (>50,000m3/d), the ERDs responsible for reducing energy consumption are only a fraction of the initial capital cost (~1-2%) of the entire plant, but offer major return on investment through energy savings.
The role that ERDs play is undeniably critical to success or failure of an RO facility.
Selecting the proper ERD system can save you millions of dollars over the life of your plant and provides peace of mind.
Specifically, isobaric, rotary-type ERDs, such as Energy Recovery Inc (ERI) PX Pressure Exchanger™ (PX™) Devices reduce consumption at an SWRO plant by as much as 60%. ERI’s best-in-class PX system provides the highest availability with an average of 99.8% uptime. The investment (ROI) of implementing PX technology is less than one year compared to an equivalent system without a PX energy recovery system. From this perspective, it is evident that the uptime of the ERD system is critical to the economics  of a plant. ERD downtime results in strict penalties, unplanned maintenance cost, and most importantly, a loss of revenue from diminished water sales and wasted cost of capital investment. In fact, margin loss due to unplanned downtime can be twice as much as the initial capital investment.
Using binomial distribution, the probability of not having an unscheduled maintenance at any point in time for a PX device is 18.32% higher than an isobaric piston-type ERD system with the same capacity.

Download PDF

Lifetime Durability of Ceramic PX Energy Recovery Devices
September 2011 | Author: Timothy Dyer

In order to ensure the long-term and trouble-free lifetime of the seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) process and its enabling technology, it is essential to utilize the most advanced and reliable materials of construction. One of the more advanced and unique materials currently in use in SWRO desalination applications is high purity (>99%) aluminum oxide (alumina) ceramics. Due to its hardness, self-lubricating properties, high compressive strength and chemical resistance, alumina ceramics create an ideal fluid bearing for the rigors of seawater applications, which perform in conditions that combine corrosive and potentially two-phase (solid/fluid) environments.
High purity alumina ceramics developed and manufactured by Energy Recovery Inc (ERI™) are particularly unique because of the innovative design of the company’s PX™ devices and the intense conditions of SWRO plants in which they operate. When in use, the ceramicbased devices are supported by a seawater fluid bearing while rotating and being pressurecycled millions of times per year. The durability of ceramics in high pressure, corrosive seawater environments is fundamental to the success of these devices and is quantified and categorized throughout this paper. The enhancement of ERI material science and technological improvements has shown to improve the overall durability of the product and significantly reduce sound levels to below 81 decibels.
Technical data shows that at peak rates, ERI ceramics inside the PX device wear at less than 3 microns per year (.003 inches over 25 years). The findings identify wear and prove that ERI alumina ceramics can last longer than 25 years in a seawater desalination reverse osmosis plant.
More than 9,700 PX units have been installed world-wide. Some units have been in operation for as long as 12 years. With zero failure as a result of PX technology designed ceramics, research indicates that PX devices will continue operating well into the future.

Download PDF

Highly Efficient Energy Recovery Devices
September 2011 | Author: Bart Biche

Energy Recovery Devices (ERDs) are at the core of saving energy in the operation of any seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) desalination facility. Isobaric or “positive displacement” devices such as the ERI PX Pressure Exchanger™ (PX™) devices are the most efficient solution available today and can reduce the energy consumption of seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) systems by up to 60 percent.
ERI has the largest installed base of ERDs in the industry. Considering only large desalination plants, ERI has a global installed base of over 9,700 individual PX devices in
more than 400 desalination plants. Factory acceptance testing is done on 100% of the  PX devices.

This paper will examine and quantify the efficiency of ERI PX devices based on an extensive database of actual test results. Significant historical performance data was evaluated and analysed to validate efficiency figures and guarantee increased efficiencies for several PX device models, including the PX Pressure Exchanger models PX-220, PX-260 and PX-300 units, The existing models offer 96.8% efficiency guarantees, which  in turn offers significant energy savings for plant owners and operators. Test data will also quantify the efficiency gains provided by ERI’s Quadribaric™ technology.
ERI’s newest device, the PX-Q300 incorporates the innovative Quadribaric technology doubling the number of pressure exchanges per revolution. This new PX-Q300 improves efficiency - with a warranted minimum efficiency of 97.2%.
Many of the globally installed units have been in operation for as long as 12 years. With zero failure as a result of PX technology designed ceramics, research indicates that PX devices will continue operating well into the future.

Download PDF

A Five Year Lifecycle Analysis of the Perth Seawater Desalination Plant
September 2011 | Author: Rodney Clemente and Greig Mercer

Facing impending water shortages in April 2005, Western Australia's Water Corporation formed a public-private partnership with global water treatment company Degrémont and constructor Multiplex. The resulting Multiplex Degrémont Joint Venture (MDJV) was tasked with design, build and commission of Perth's first large seawater desalination plant in just 18 months. In November 2006, the 144,000 m3 /day (38 million U.S. gallons per day) seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) plant began delivering desalinated water into Perth’s municipal water supply. At the time of commissioning, the Perth Seawater Desalination Plant (PSDP) was the largest SWRO plant operating in the southern hemisphere and the largest single source of water for the city of Perth, supplying approximately 17% of the city’s needs.

In addition to the short implementation timeline, MDJV was faced with several challenges in the design of the Perth SWRO plant. The public demanded energy efficiency and limited greenhouse gas emissions, therefore, the PSDP became the largest plant to have its power consumption offset with renewable energy generation. To further reduce the power consumed and greenhouse gasses emitted by the RO process, Energy Recovery Inc’s PX Pressure Exchanger technology was implemented into the process design in what was, at the time, the largest installation of these devices.

This paper will demonstrate how sustained long-term energy efficiency can be achieved in large-scale SWRO plants. Performance of the energy recovery system during commissioning of the PSDP will be compared to performance measured onsite nearly five years later. The importance of proper system design and operation for achieving maximum performance and longevity will be addressed. In addition, the role of advanced materials in sustaining performance over the designed life of the plant will be considered.
 

Download PDF

A Case Study: Energy Use and Process Design Considerations for Four Desalination Plants in California
September 2011 | Author: Juan Miguel Pinto and Erik Desormeaux

California is the 7th largest economy in the world with a significant need for drinking water and irrigation water for agriculture to keep up with the state’s current needs and future demands. As part of this need, California has funded projects related to more than 10 proposed desalination plants across the state through Proposition 50, a grant program administered by the State Department of Water Resources.

While the majority of these projects have been pilot and demonstration scale research studies, many of the full-scale projects have been delayed due to permitting challenges, public opposition, and political challenges. This paper presents information about the Sand City, Cambria, Santa Cruz, and Dana Point projects with each facility at different stages of project development and requiring different solutions to move the project forward.

The Sand City Desalination Facility, located in Monterey County, California, is the first full-scale, municipal desalination plant in California permitted under the new surface water treatment regulations. The facility has a capacity of 2.3 million liters per day (MLD) and produces approximately 1.1 MLD on average. Additionally, design features led to nearly $100,000 in rebates for energy efficiency measures expected to save more than 1.2 million kilowatt-hours of electricity and 667 tons of greenhouse gas emissions per year.

The Cambria Desalination Facility was on track to be the second full-scale, municipal desalination plant in California. However, permitting issues related to intake location and selection has delayed the project. The proposed facility will produce up to 3.8 MLD.

The proposed scwd2 Desalination Facility in Santa Cruz will produce up to 9.5 MLD and is currently in the preliminary design and permitting phase. Several in-depth studies have been completed to identify and demonstrate solutions to address concerns from the public and regulators.

Lastly this paper will present an update on the Dana Point Desalination Facility which will produce up to 56 MLD and is currently in the pilot-testing and planning phase. This project will be the first to implement slant wells for a subsurface intake.This paper presents information on process selection, energy consumption, and related topics for these four existing and planned projects in California.

Download PDF

SWRO Energy Recovery Devices: Pushing the Envelope of Materials Capabilities
May 2011 | Author: Timonthy Dyer, Eric Kadaj, Jeremy Martin

Energy recovery devices (ERD) have played a key role in enabling cost effective seawater desalination. Ironically, increasing efficiency and reliability requirements for large water factories are now pushing energy recovery devices to the next level of performance. Expectations are ever increasing in terms of reliability, efficiency, availability, and lower operational costs. Simply put, expectations are high and units must operate trouble free in one of the most corrosive and inhospitable industrial environments known. Energy recovery efficiency is still paramount; however reliability, serviceability, customer support, and system availability are becoming all equally important to our customers.  

Download PDF

New Concept of Upgrade Energy Recovery Systems Within An Operating Desalination Plant.
October 2010 | Author: Juan Miguel Pinto, Avner Hermony

The Palmachim Desalination plant is one of the largest seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) desalination plants in Israel with a capacity of 120,000 cubic meters per day. Built by the Via Maris Desalination Ltd. consortium, the plant consists of six (6) parallel SWRO trains, each with a permeate production capacity of up to 20,000 cubic meters per day. In addition its high-capacity SWRO trains, the Palmachim plant is unique because it was designed to be easily turned on, off or slowed down. Electricity tariffs in Israel are significantly higher during the day than at night with a cost ratio of up to six to one. The plant’s flexibility allows the operators to minimize energy consumption during the day when the power cost is high by shutting down up to 85% of the plants capacity.

Download PDF

Brackish Water Desalination: Energy and Cost Considerations
August 2010 | Author: Jeremy Martin, Douglas Eisberg

Energy recovery devices are employed in nearly all seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) desalination plants to recover pressure from the membrane reject stream and return it to the process. Because of the high pressures and low membrane permeate recovery rates common in these systems, the membrane reject stream contains a considerable amount of energy. The use of energy recovery devices in seawater RO is readily justified on the basis of operating cost savings. However, the application of energy recovery is much less common in brackish water RO systems, primarily because of the relatively low feed pressure and low flow rate of the membrane reject stream. The fear is that energy recovery devices can also potentially limit the flexibility of a brackish RO process because of efficiency losses or flow-rate constraints encountered during off-peak operation.

Download PDF

Desalination and Energy Efficiency for a Uranium Mine in Namibia
June 2010 | Author: Martin Pryor, Borja Blanco, Joan Galtes

The authors present energy saving solutions for desalination water supply for mining applications. Detailed design data for the Uranium mining desalination plant are given. Environment and economic conscious owners and operators will learn methods of design and operation of desalination systems in mining, which can be easily extrapolated to many other industrial needs, and how to minimize the total cost of ownership of a desalination process.

Download PDF